strawberry custard pie

strawberry custard pie


I’m gonna make you a strawberry pie maker. And, it’s gonna be so easy! Yes, you’ll be the star making this strawberry custard pie! Super simple!

Funny how the thought and memory of a strawberry can conjure up memories of growing up in Southern West Virginia. Stick with me because the strawberry is the catalyst of this memory.

Strawberry Pie

When I was a little girl, one of the treats we had as kids was to go for a drive on Sunday. Certainly not every Sunday by no means. Probably three or four Sundays a year.

Now, drives were special because we’d usually stop some place to eat. Mom and Dad would pile us four kids into the 1954 Ford where the seats still had the plastic cover on them, and they’d try to enjoy themselves while the four of us would end up fussing and fighting in the backseat.

There wasn’t much in the way of dining to choose from, but depending upon our drive, we might have something really ‘ritzy’ like the ‘Glasshouse’ on the West Virginia turnpike or a mom and pop diner in a nearby small town.

Custard Strawberry Pie

Occasionally, our family would take a long drive, maybe because we kids were being good, to Charleston where we’d go to Shoney’s. Yes, Shoneys home of the ‘Big Boy’ and a chain of restaurants, some still around, that started in the 1950s. If you’ve never been there, then you don’t know this. They have the best strawberry pie around!

Strawberry Custard Filling

Yes, it’s their signature strawberry pie. Now while my strawberry custard pie is no where like Shoney’s version, the reason I share this is because when I create recipes, I draw upon my history, my legacy, my memories, and my experiences, which give me that inspiration to make something. Yep, that’s the case here.

Fresh Strawberry Custard Pie Recipe

I was thinking of Mom and Dad, us four brats, all piled into that beat up 1954 Ford doing the ‘family’ thing that in all probability was pureTEE torture for Mom and Dad. But, God bless ’em, they tried so hard to give us exposure to the ‘finer’ things in life and expand our small world in those mountains of Southern West Virginia to the big city. For another glimpse into my past.

Strawberry Pies

I’m gonna make you a pie maker. Specifically, I’m talking strawberry pies. And, it’s gonna be so easy! Yes, you’ll be the star making this strawberry custard pie! Super simple!

No Bake Strawberry Dessert

Baked Strawberry Pie

There is nothing better than fresh sweet in-season strawberries. And, when you get them, you are ready to overdose on this berry goodliness!

We know that there are upteen zillion ways to use strawberries. I mean they are just so versatile and perfect for both sweet and savory dishes. But, the quintessential way, I think, to use them is in strawberry pies.


There are various ways to make custard. And, my version of making custard for this strawberry pie is so simple. You’ll use two ingredients. And, the custard is going to bake in the pie. Custard is basically eggs (yolks), milk (or cream) and sugar.

Custard Peach Pie

Easy Apple Custard Tart

Custard Filling Recipe

But, with sweetened condensed milk we have the sugar and milk combined then all we need to do is whisk in the eggs. When all this is poured over those fresh ripe juicy strawberries and baked in the oven, well, you get a delicious custard. Pretty simple, right! That’s what cooking should be, easy! 


strawberry custard pie

strawberry custard pie

strawberry custard pie

I'm gonna make you a strawberry pie maker. And, it's gonna be so easy! Yes, you'll be the star making this strawberry custard pie! Super simple!


  • Preheat oven to 350
  • 1 refrigerated roll up pie crust, somewhat room temperature & rolled out
  • 16 oz. package fresh strawberries, tops trimmed off & sliced lengthwise into 2-4 pieces
  • ½ cup sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 eggs, divided
  • ½ lemon, zest & juice


  1. Coat a 9” pie plate with cooking spray. Lay the pie crust in the plate. Let it drape over the pie plate.
  2. Plate the strawberries in a concentric circle on the crust. Add the lemon zest and juice on the berries.
  3. In a small bowl, mix the sweetened condensed milk, one egg and one egg yolk. Reserve the egg white for brushing the crust before baking.
  4. Pour the custard mix over the berries. Fold over and pinch together the pie crust draping over the pie plate. Use a pastry brush and coat this crust.
  5. Bake in a preheated 350 oven for 35-40 minutes. Remove to a cooling rack and cool about an hour.

Your sharing is GOLDEN! Thank you!

Your sharing and comments help me stay in business! Share a photo if you make the recipe #allyskitchen Thank you! xo Ally

strawberry custard pie


Similar Posts


  1. Vanessa Keever says:

    Thanks alot for sharing! Someone gave me a lot of strawberries! I really like to try this out!

  2. Sorry, Ally, I was underwhelmed with this pie. I followed the recipe exactly, except I cooked it about 15 minutes more than the recipe suggested because it did not appear to be done. After cooling for an hour, we tried a slice of pie. The crust on the bottom was gooey and not cooked, and the filling was way too runny. It had decent strawberry taste, but was not very appealing. I will not be making this again.

    1. Gosh, Lori, I’m so so sorry for this outcome. And, I sincerely appreciate your letting me know. I’ll be sure to remake and see how it works again for me. May I share this recipe which is very similar, however, it uses another type crust (you can also make this crust from scratch if you prefer, sometimes I do). Not sure what area of the world you’re in, but when peaches are in season, we love this! Again, thank you, and I hope you’ll look at other things to try! xo ally

  3. Gwen Gobble says:

    This recipe is a keeper. The pie looks delicious and the simple ingredients appeal to me.

    1. Oh, Gwen! I sure hope you make it. It’s so easy. Always love having you here xoxx

    1. Hey, Toni! Thanks for checking it out! So simple, it’s one you’ll make often! xo ~ally

    1. Megan!! Thank you! That’s the best compliment evvvahhhhh!! xo ~ally

    1. Miss Kelsie!! You’re getting the wholebpie, luv!! Thank you!!

  4. LOVE the video! Someone just asked me what to make for a dinner party he is having tomorrow night. I am going to tell him to bake this pie. Thank you!

    1. Merrreeeee! Thank you!!! You make me dance and twirl!! This pie’s really good. And, you see EZ PZ! Miss you girl! xoxo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.