silky coconut pie

silky coconut pie

Just the name silky coconut pie makes you want to savor a bite of this amazing delicacy. Creamy coconutEEE and absolutely easy and delicious! 

Easy Coconut Cream Pie

Ya know, I used to be intimidated about making homemade custard or cream for a pie filling. I just thought it would be so complicated. But, boy was I wrong. 

Coconut Custard Pie

Coconut pie with a silky creamy custard is so simple to make. Now, the big deal about this is paying attention to the custard as you’re making it. 

Coconut Custard

Coconut custard is simple egg yolks, milk, always whole but I prefer half and half, that’s half whole milk and half cream. And, you’ll see that I’m also using coconut milk. Now you do not want anything but whole coconut milk. No low fat. It’s got to be the real deal.

Then you’ve got sugar to sweeten and vanilla extract to bring out more flavor. To add a tad bit more thickening to it, I’m using corn starch. 

Creamy Coconut Pie

This creamy coconut pie gets better on days two and three. And, yes, when you keep it refrigerated and covered tightly with plastic wrap, it’s going to be tasty for a couple of days. Well, if it lasts that long. 

Coconut Cream Pie with Coconut Cream

The technique with coconut cream is to pay attention as I said. You’ll gently let it come to a simmering boil. Then you’ll whisk occasionally as you’re standing there at the stove. No, please don’t walk away. I know I know, this is a bit ‘high maintenance’ but it’s totally worth it. 

Coconut Cream Bars

I’m making this coconut cream pie in a square baking dish. So is it really a pie or are these coconut cream bars? I love the square or rectangular shapes that we can cut. And, if you want to get creative, cut into squares, then slice each square diagonally and make triangles. Just a littl’ extra flair for serving. 

Custard Pie 

Silky coconut custard pie is perfect for any occasion and for any season. My recipe doesn’t give you an overly sweet pie. You’re going to have more of the velvety cream with the flavor of coconut. Now I’m using shredded sweetened coconut, but you could also use frozen sweetened coconut in the filling. I’ll always toast coconut to finished off the top of the pie just for some added golden brown happiness. 

Coconut Custard Pie Recipe

Besides this coconut custard pie recipe, I have an insanely even easier, if that’s possible, custard peach pie. Honestly, you will not believe how quick it is to make. Then when strawberries are in season, why not try my strawberry custard pie! And, apple season? I have you covered with my easy apple custard tart

Check out some more pie & cakes recipes:
spicy chocolate red dragon cookie sandwich
cocoa espresso babovka

silky coconut pie

silky coconut pie

silky coconut pie

Yield: One 8 x 8 baking dish


  • CRUST:
  • 3 cups graham crackers, crushed
  • 1 ½ cups sliced almonds, crushed
  • ½ cup wheat germ
  • 8 Tbl. butter, salted, melted
  • 2 cups half and half
  • 1 cup coconut cream milk, full fat, not refrigerated type coconut milk
  • 6 large egg yolks
  • 1 Tbl. cornstarch
  • 1 tsp. vanilla
  • ½ cup coconut sugar, can substitute regular sugar
  • 3 cups coconut, shredded sweetened + more for toasting and garnish


Combine the crushed graham crackers, almonds, wheat germ and
butter. Blend and mix well. Put in an 8x8 baking dish. Pat down the mixture
well. Bake in a preheated 350 oven for 6 minutes to set crust. Remove and let
it cool thoroughly.

In a large saucepan, whisk together the cream, egg yolks, sugar
cornstarch and vanilla. Turn heat to medium high and let the mixture come to a
simmering boil for about 2 minutes. Be sure to stir and blend occasionally as
this is heating and begins to simmer boil.

Reduce heat to medium. Sauce with thicken as the mixture continues
to simmer boil (stir occasionally so mixture does not burn on bottom) another
about 5 to 6 minutes. Once the cream is a velvety sauce, remove from heat and
add 3 cups of the shredded coconut and blend.

Put plastic wrap on top the mixture. Place in the
refrigerator to chill about 30 minutes.

When the cream filling is chilled, pour on top the crust.
Smooth and blend.

With the remaining coconut, spread on a parchment paper
lined cookie sheet. Place about 8-10” from the broiler. Turn on broil and toast
the coconut to a golden brown. Remove. Cool. Sprinkle on top the pie.

Refrigerate the pie several hours before serving. 

Your sharing is GOLDEN! Thank you!

Your sharing and comments help me stay in business! Share a photo if you make the recipe #allyskitchen Thank you! xo Ally

silky coconut pie




Similar Posts


  1. Karen Anderson says:

    I might be missing something here (I have a migraine today) but when does the sugar go in?

    1. Oh, Karen! Thank you for bring that to my attention! That sugar goes into the cream mixture w/the eggs, milk, cornstarch. Of course, by now, you probably did figure that out. So sorry! Sometimes my brain overlooks things as I’m typing out recipes. This is a great reminder to slow down!! xo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.